Skip to content

The foot-stamping of the audience told its own story

Bachtrack, Phil Parker
Four Stars

If anyone in the audience believed the fiction that playing the piano is the genteel activity beloved of melancholy heroines of 19th-century novels, then 90 minutes in the company of resident Sheffield pianist Tim Horton and guest Ivana Gavrić would surely be enough to dispel that misconception for ever.

“This was piano playing at its most brutal and visceral, and I hasten to add that I mean that in the most complimentary way.”

Stravinsky’s own two-piano arrangement of his ballet The Rite of Spring attempts the almost impossible – to condense the richly textured sound world of a huge symphony orchestra into the essentially monochrome palette of the piano keyboard – but what is lost in orchestral texture is more than compensated for in its focus on The Rite’s principal mode of operation: rhythm.

“Horton and Gavrić, enabled by the Crucible Playhouse’s enclosed, in-the-round intimacy, made us feel the work’s hammer blows, its primal ferocity, as though absorbed by our very bodies. Not that the performance was all sound and fury: the yearning bassoon solo at the start and the quivering flute melodies of the work’s second movement sang hauntingly in their keyboard guise. “

 But what lingered long after the final decisive chord had been struck was the sense of having witnessed something being almost savagely reborn: outside, the icy streets of sub-zero Sheffield, but inside, the violent cracking of the sudden onrush of the Russian spring. As Horton and Gavrić shared a warm (possibly rather exhausted) embrace, the foot-stamping of the audience told its own story.

…The works by Shostakovich and Rachmaninov in the first half of the programme were delivered with the same commitment, even if they are clearly worlds apart in their musical language.

Rachmaninov’s Suite no.1 (“Fantaisie-Tableaux”) is the work of a teenager, but one with almost full access to the rhetorical tricks of the adult composer he would become. The mature Rachmaninov’s fingerprints are everywhere here: rising and falling triplet figures, arpeggiated chords, the relentless ostinati that drove the more exultant sections of the piece with an almost motoric energy… the performers clearly love the music, and their engagement with it was compelling, in the lachrymose third movement as much as in the ringing finale.

In some ways Shostakovich’s Concertino in A minor felt like the odd man out here, depicting not so much renewal as relief, at having survived the Stalin years more or less intact… Horton and Gavrić balanced its brittle humour with the shadow of something far more sombre.

Photo Credit: Matthew Johnson

You may also like to see...
A terrific performance

ArtMuse, Karine Hetherington
Horton takes advice from the old Master and gets a standing ovation for his Chopin Scherzos

A performance of thrilling tension and excitement

Bachtrack, Phil Parker
Four Stars

Sensitivity and insight

Musical Opinion, Paul Conway

A magisterial solo recital

The Arts Desk, Clare Stevens

Great empathy for the music’s demands

Bachtrack, Phil Parker
Five Stars

This performance was thrilling

Bachtrack, Phil Parker
Four Stars

A hugely committed, triumphant performance

The Strad, Edward Bhesania

Stott and Horton deserved their standing ovation

Bachtrack, Phil Parker

Graceful, urbane playing

The Strad, Tim Homfray

Exquisite sensitivity and timing

BBC Music Magazine, Julian Haylock
Five Stars

The most sympathetic of interpreters

BBC Music Magazine, Geoff Brown
Four Stars

Colours and textures of ravishing intensity and radiance

Music Web International, Richard Hanlon

Entirely engaging

Gramophone, Harriet Smith

Uniformly excellent

The Arts Desk, Graham Rickson

Tim Horton’s unaffected, heartfelt playing is perfectly judged

The Arts Desk, Graham Rickson

Suitably virtuosic verve

The Guardian, Stephen Pritchard

Marvelously dovetailed interplay

Classics Today, Jed Distler

Unsurpassable performances

Gramophone, Richard Bratby

Soaring potency and impassioned eloquence

The Strad, Julian Haylock

Fresh, intelligent and strikingly stylish

Gramophone, Richard Bratby

Wise and generous interpreters

Music Web International, Jonathan Woolf

Played with conviction and oneness

Classical Source, Colin Anderson
Five Stars

Lively and evocative performance

BBC Music Magazine, Daniel Jaffé
Five Stars

Fine interpreters

BBC Music Magazine, Claire Jackson
Four Stars

The Leonore give a spirited reading

Gramophone, Harriet Smith

Fine playing

Music Web International, Jim Westhead

Compelling

Gramophone, Geoffrey Norris

Characterful performance

Music Web International, Michael Cookson

Raw noise and mixed emotions

The Times, Paul Driver

Superb light, dazzling backgrounds from Tim Horton

BBC Music Magazine, Jessica Duchen
Four Stars

High virtuosity all round

BBC Music Magazine, Jessica Duchen
Four Stars

Stunning performances

Music Web International, Michael Cookson

Luminous performances

Gramophone, Geoffrey Norris

Tim Horton shone

The Guardian, Alfred Hickling

It is hard to imagine playing of a greater empathy

Gramophone, Bryce Morrison

Sumptuous breadth and beguiling warmth

The Observer, Stephen Pritchard

Revelatory playing

The Observer, Stephen Pritchard

The excellent Tim Horton

The Strad, Carlos María Solare

Back To Top
18/11/2026