Skip to content

Performers are of the top rank

MusicWeb International, Rob Barnett

English 20th century composer Pamela Harrison was born in Orpington and was an RCM student of Gordon Jacob and Arthur Benjamin. She was the wife (divorced in 1959) of the cellist Harvey Phillips, whose eponymous orchestra often broadcast on the Third Programme. She lived on the North Downs, Dartmoor and then Castle Cary.

..

The Clarinet Quintet – first performed by Jack Brymer with the Hirsch quartet – is a thing of irrepressible songfulness. Harrison marries this with episodes driven with urgency and disrupted by jazzy cross-currents. This latter quality alternates with calm in an ebb-and-flow pattern. The middle movement is typically elegiac but with an ascending intensity. It is longer than other two put together and forms the coping stone for this quarter-hour work. The finale radiates a poignant Finzi-like joie de vivre.

The Sonnet is, like a few other works here, very short and is a peaceful ‘haiku’. The notes tell us that this is a love song; if so, it is a love that is generous, and does not possess or cajole. The Violin Sonatina variously dances, shivers with a knowledge of the ephemeral nature of life and is devoid of nostalgia. On the contrary, it is instinct with recollection of the loss of years part. The finale is almost twice as long as II and III together. It has a quick pace and a calypso-like rolling gait. Faggot Dance is another short jewel of a piece for flowingly Poulenc-like bassoon. It is not at all long-winded; even short pieces can be long-winded.

The Clarinet Sonata (1953) was said to be ‘gritty’; again, it’s associated with Jack Brymer.

This three-movement work is played with feeling, the piano seeming to cry out.

The finale is one of cartwheeling urgency which has, as a counter-balance, the lyric voice that is the natural province of the clarinet. Drifting away – an outlier, first performed in 1975, was also associated with Brymer. It is bound up in Yeats’ line “All that’s beautiful drifts away like the waters”. The brief sketch Idle Dan for cello and piano, is more of a glance than a mood picture; a breeze-blown doze in a hammock. The Piano Trio – again in three movements – is a work of light touch nostalgia. The listener will experience a seething Howellsian lyricism and a finale that evokes ringing bells with as much impact as Vaughan Williams’ “Noisy bells” and the clangour that rounds out, in tear-stained triumph, the finale of Falla’s El Amor Brujo.

The booklet essay (English only) is by Robert Plane.

As we have come to expect from Resonus, both the performers and the recording quality are of the top rank.

This disc offers a welcome embrace to the listener and seeker after the higher reaches of art in English music.

You may also like to see...
This performance was thrilling

Bachtrack, Phil Parker
Four Stars

The players were especially alert to dynamic shading

Musical Opinion, Paul Conway

Reawakened
Plane has magisterial control of his instrument

British Music Society, Geoffrey Atkinson

Reawakened
They’re real gems

BBC Radio 3 Record Review, Andrew McGregor

Best Re-Issue

Classic FM, David Mellor

Utterly beguiling

The Westmorland Gazette, Ian Jones

Wistful beauty

The Times, Anna Picard

Afternoon Concert
Very smooth and subtle and deeply musical

BBC Radio 3, Kate Molleson

Unleashed with a controlled power by these fine musicians

The Scotsman, Susan Nickalls

Robert Plane
Threw himself into his athletic lines with glee and abandon
Plane’s tireless virtuosity

The Guardian, Rian Evans

Robert Plane Contrasts - Impressions Of Hungary
It's a little gem

The Guardian, Erica Jeal 

Robert Plane
A Perfect Partnership at the Ilkley Concert Club

Sacconi Quartet and Robert Plane at the King’s Hall, Chris Skidmore

Robert Plane gives a very fine reading [of Finzi Clarinet Concerto] for Naxos

From “Which is the best recording of Finzi’s Clarinet Concerto?” by Patrick Rucker, 14th July 2016

Robert Plane, Philip Dukes and Huw Watkins – unerring control

The Guardian, Rian Evans

A perfect balance of structural exactitude and lyricism – Gould Trio with clarinettist Robert Plane

The Guardian, Rian Evans

Further Reviews
Immaculately performed by Robert Plane

The Guardian, Andrew Clements

Consistent musicality and enthusiasm

The Sir Arnold Bax Website, Christopher Webber and Graham Parlett

At the very top of their game

Gramophone, Andrew Achenbach

His instrumental skill is stunning

Craven Herald, Adrienne Fox

Delectable soloist

International Record Review

First-class

Fanfare

Plane’s readings are superb

Gramophone, Jeremy Dibble

Soulful clarinet-playing of Robert Plane

Gramophone, Richard Whitehouse

Music-making of the highest calibre

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Four Stars

Robert Plane an inspired soloist

Gramophone, Edward Greenfield

Characteristically intricate

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Four Stars

Brilliantly adept

The Arts Desk, Stephen Walsh

Ravishing lyricism and conviction

Gramophone, Jeremy Dibble

Nothing short of exceptional

Gramophone, Jeremy Dibble

Depth of musical character

Irish Times, Michael Dervan

Robert Plane Ref 001 2019 Please Credit Sara Porter Www.saraporterphotography.co.uk Smed
Bright, gymnastic

The Observer, Anthony Holden

Ravishing in tone

Gramophone, Andrew Achenbach

Plane’s clarinet has an eloquent and expressive voice

The Times, Rick Jones

Irreproachably alert and stylish

Gramophone, Andrew Achenbach

Entrancing poise and liquid tone

Gramophone, Andrew Achenbach

Ravishing range of tone and natural warmth

The Guardian, Edward Greenfield
Five Stars

Lyrical sweeps of phrasing in an immaculate performance

BBC, Andrew McGregor 

Effortless technical mastery

Gramophone, Andrew Achenbach

Back To Top
17/01/2025