Skip to content

Musical fire

The Reviews Hub, Ron Simpson

The latest in the University of Sheffield’s concert season at Firth Hall saw the Gould Piano Trio performing two trios from the classical tradition sandwiching a striking modern piece by James MacMillan. The Gould Trio consists of immensely experienced and talented chamber and solo musicians…

“Their 25 years-plus together was reflected in the precision of their playing and their control of balance and dynamics, especially in the Beethoven Trio [no. 2, op. 70].”

…

Before the interval James MacMillan’s 14 Little Pieces for Piano Trio sprang a surprise: not 14 separate miniatures, but a through-composed 20-minute piece, full of contrasts and frequently singling out one or more of the instruments: strings set against piano, cello combined with piano and so on. Benjamin Frith in particular covered a huge dynamic range, the piano part often thunderous, finishing with a series of piano chords of increasing intensity, echoed softly by Richard Lester’s cello. At another time the music entered a dream-like sequence. It was easy to understand Lucy Gould’s comment that the trio love this piece, with all its contrasts and technical demands – and they shared that enjoyment with a slightly perplexed, but enthralled, audience.

At the end of the concert, after MacMillan’s pyrotechnics and Beethoven’s sunny mastery, it was easy to forget the opener: Brahms’ Piano Trio No. 3, opus 101, but this, too, made its impact, from the drama of the opening through the dance rhythms and the emotional andante to the eloquent violin melody leading to the rousing finale.

“All in all, it was a neatly contrasted concert performed with complete control and, where needed, musical fire.”

You may also like to see...
Sheer delight … played with such love

Charles Hutch Press, Martin Dreyer

A premiere performance of commitment and flair

Musical Opinion, Paul Conway

A lovely late morning recital … grace and charm

BachTrack, Mark Pullinger

Commitment and excellence

Ilkey Concert Club, Chris Skidmore

Vivid dynamic contrasts … majestic … spellbinding

The Strad, Tim Homfray

Intense, nourishing playing … mysterious and tremendous … blazing conviction

The Telegraph, Ivan Hewett

Immaculate attention to detail of articulation … warm, silken sound

BBC Music Magazine, Natasha Loges

Spontaneous, unforced and imaginative

The Strad, Robin Stowell

Unanimity of approach … faultless performances

Gramophone, David Threasher

Chamber music heaven … the perfect lockdown tonic

The Times, Geoff Brown

Clarity and balance

Gramophone, Richard Whitehouse

A welcome release … the excellence of the Gould’s playing

Gramophone, Richard Whitehouse

These performances make for a very enjoyable CD

Lark Reviews, Stephen Page

Lyrical beauty, burning brio and an awesome degree of ensemble spirit

BBC Music Magazine, Geoff Brown

Brilliant throughout
Drama and refinement

Gramophone, Tim Ashley

Unshowy sparkle

Financial Times, Richard Fairman

Intensely expressive

The Strad, Andrew Farach-Colton

Fire and expressive power

The Guardian, Rian Evans

A ravishing performance by the Goulds

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Four Stars

Ebullience and verve

The Strad, Edward Bhesania

Wonderful performances

Music Web International, Stuart Sillitoe

Fine blending between all members

Bachtrack, Philip May
Four Stars

Confident, precise ensemble playing

Gramophone, Duncan Druce

Deep sensitivity

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Four Stars

Consistent musicality and enthusiasm

The Sir Arnold Bax Website, Christopher Webber and Graham Parlett

A wealth of expressive detail

The Guardian, Rian Evans

Understated virtuosity and startling clarity

Washington Post, Robert Battey

Superb performances

The Guardian, Andrew Clements

Unsurpassably played

Yorkshire Live, Val Javin

Nimble, agile and intense

The Guardian, Fiona Maddocks

Played with a delicate touch

BBC Music Magazine, Misha Donat
Four Stars

Telepathic connection

Bachtrack, Emily Owen
Four Stars

Revelatory interpretations

The Guardian, Stephen Prichard

Profoundly musical

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Five Stars

Freshness, panache, charm

BBC Music Magazine, Erik Levi
Five Stars

Excellent performances

BBC Music Magazine, Calum MacDonald
Five Stars

Astonishing accuracy

Bachtrack, Alexandra Hamilton-Ayres

Music-making of the highest calibre

The Guardian, Rian Evans
Four Stars

The performances here are very sympathetic

Classics Today, David Hurwitz

Uncommonly powerful and disturbing

The Independent, Anna Picard

Back To Top
11/10/2026